Bait Bikes Theft in Austin: Entrapment or Impulsive Theft?

A rash of bike thefts in Austin, Travis County (and probably many major cities) has prompted Austin Police Department to focus on Bike Theft crimes downtown, by leaving high priced bicycles at street poles, fences, and sidewalks across the city -- unlocks and unguarded.

Many of these "bait bikes" are left on Campus at UT, and all are equipped with a tracking GPS linked to Austin Police computers.

While some might be locked with a cheap chain or other minor security measure, many are merely leaning against a bike rack, or wrapped to a light pole by an unlocked bike chain.

So what happens when someone decides to take one of the expensive, new bikes? Well, Austin Police tracks the movement and and swoop in for a Theft Arrest.  And, since the bike is expensive (typically around $650-800), and since they include the price of the GPS unit which is attached to the bike (and likewise stolen -- valued at nearly $400), the grand total of the Theft gets the person to a Class A Misdemeanor Bike Theft.

So the first thing people say, is: Entrapment!  Unfortunately, Entrapment is a very narrow defense, meaning it's only available in a few cases.  Theft in the above described situation would NOT be able to take advantage of Entrapment, because, put simply, the person was free to merely walk away.  There was no trap that forced the person to act illegally; instead, the legal course of action would have been to keep walking, which the person was free to do.

A potential defense, although not a good one, could also be Abandoned Property.  The problem is that an Abandoned Property Defense requires the person finding the property to do several things BEFORE taking the item, such as (among other things) trying to find the rightful owner.  While an Abandoned Property defense could work, more information and investigation would be needed to show that there was no Theft.

The best option, now that you know the dangers of Bait Bikes, is to avoid the bike at all costs.

Basics of a Texas DWI in Austin, Travis County

A typical DWI arrest consists of being pulled over while driving, usually for swerving or bad driving observed by an officer. Frequently, other suspicious drivers may call 911 or a DWI hot line to report other drivers on the road.

Once an officer has pulled over an individual for DWI, the officer with conduct several observations to further establish reasonable suspicion or probable cause, such as looking for blood shot eyes, slurred speech, unsteady gait or fumbling with documents, and the smell of alcohol. While pure alcohol has no smell, officers will frequently testify that the flavoring in alcohol (the other additives in the drink) has a distinct smell when consumed and on the breath.

After making preliminary observations, the officer will usually conduct field sobriety tests, or FSTs. The FSTs consist of several physical tests that are commonly thought to gauge a person's intoxication level. Some of the field sobriety tests used are the walk and turn test, finger tip to nose test, stand on one leg test, silent count to thirty test, and the Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus test.

Many times, either before or after the FSTs, an officer will ask the driver of a suspected DWI to breathe into a machine commonly called a breathalyzer or breath test device, used to calculate a person's intoxication by measuring the alcohol content at that moment in the breath.

If the result of a breath or blood test reads at or above a .08%, the driver is generally arrested for DWI, although the results need not be at a .08 or above to arrest. DWI Arrests can be made at breath or even blood test levels below a .08%, if the officer believes the person is too intoxicated to drive. Travis County has been known to prosecute DWI cases based on lower than .08% blood alcohol levels.

At a DWI arrest, an officer will hand the driver a notice of driver's license suspension, which is sent to the Texas DPS. A person arrested on a DWI charge has the right to appeal the driver's license suspension at the DPS with a formal administrative hearing. Typically the arresting officer will testify at the DPS hearing, setting forth the suspected probable cause for arrest and suspension of the driver's license. The key is to request the hearing within ten days of DWI arrest -- within 10 days! -- in order to conduct the DPS hearing, otherwise, the right to an administrative DWI DPS hearing is waived and lost.

DWI in Texas: Can you get a DWI from Prescription Drugs in Texas (No Alcohol DWIs - Drugged Driving)

In Texas, DWI laws are changing each year, often to make penalties and punishments more sever for DWI offenders, as well as creating more ways for law enforcement to make arrests.  I often receive calls about DWI arrests where no alcohol was involved -- but instead, the person was arrested for DWI based on a Prescription Medication.

Lunesta is one of the most common I see, although many other narcotics -- all legal with prescription -- have led to arrests and in many cases, convictions for DWI.

Texas Law specifically states, "

"Intoxicated" means: not having the normal use of mental or physical faculties by reason of the introduction of alcohol, a controlled substance, a drug, a dangerous drug, a combination of two or more of those substances, or any other substance into the body."

Which means, DWI's are not limited to alcohol any longer, and include drugs -- even a legal, prescribed medication.

However, a non-alcohol DWI is far harder to prove than alcohol DWIs.  First, the prosecutors won't have much to go on if they don't test your blood, and I've seen many cases where blood is not tested.  Without blood results (which would show traces and potentially, depending on the test, the metabolites of the drug in your system) then the prosecutors must attempt to prove the case on circumstantial evidence.  They'll show that you were on a medication, or admitted to being on a prescription at the time of driving, and will point to driving errors or errors on the field sobriety tests to show impairment.

There is no legal limit, in terms of a numerical value, for medication DWI.  In other words, while it's prohibited to drive with more than .08% of alcohol in your system, leaving the prosecution to rely heavily on "impairment" in general.  Often they argue that any impairment is enough to prove DWI, but it's important to note that impairment must rise to the degree that it interferes with the ability to drive.  And that, is more difficult to prove to a jury than merely being over .08%, as in an Alcohol DWI.

What is the Difference in a Dismissal and Expunction in Texas?

Under Texas Law, there is a difference between a Dismissal of a Criminal Offense, and an Expunction of a Criminal Offense.  So which one is better for you?  The answer is obvious: Expunction.

A criminal case that is Dismissed means that the case is no longer pending, and there was no final finding of guilt by a Judge.  There are several ways a case can be dismissed, including Deferred Prosecution, Deferred Disposition, Dismissed for Insufficiency of the Evidence, or in the Interest of Justice.

Currently, as of this writing, if the case was Dismissed, and there are no other related cases that ended in a Conviction (such as a second charge, reduce charge arising from the same facts as the Dismissal), then the case SHOULD be eligible for Expunction.

Beware: Dismissals after Deferred Adjudication Probation are not considered a full Dismissal in terms of Expunction eligibility.

So why is Expunction so great? Why is Expunction better than letting the case remain a mere Dismissal? Because on an Expunction, the Judge Orders the state agencies that hold your record to destroy your paperwork and records.  Essentaillyu, the existence of the arrest, citation, and court proceedings are destroyed.

Expunction Law is always changing, so call us to see what we can do -- before the law changes again.

Will my Arrest (or Ticket) Show Up on a Criminal Background Check in Texas?

One of the first questions I get asked when a prospective client calls me is: "Will this arrest or ticket show up on my Criminal Background Check?"  Arrests or tickets -- even for very minor things like Drunk in Public -- can be embarrassing and often cost people their jobs.

Imagine a prospective employer, roommate, or someone you're dating Google's your name, and the first thing to show up is your mug shot.

Yes, in Texas they will take a mug shot for offenses that might not even result in jail time, like a Public Intoxication.  Which is why it's important to know your rights and how to keep your mistakes private.

Unfortunately, the law in Texas does not help.  In Texas, despite the presumption of Innocent until proven guilty, Texas police and courts forward the arrest, citation, and tickets to DPS, which is the Texas Department of Public Safety; basically a Super DMV.  DPS tracks all arrests and tickets in a central database.

But to make things worse, DPS can legally begin selling that information to private businesses.  yes, that's right; your arrest information is SOLD to businesses that report criminal history information on the Internet.  The great majority of purchasers run online background check services, and instantly can list the arrest, citation, or tickets, with you name, date of birth, and area of offense.

The problem is that often times, a first time offender here in Austin, Travis County Texas, can get the benefit of the doubt and possibly have the case dismissed.  Or, to a greater degree of being problematic, there are people arrested for crimes they did not commit -- and have the case dismissed within a few days of being arrested.  For those people, if they take no action, the arrest will still show up on a Criminal History Report.  Now, both are eligible for Expunction, with the former needing to wait possibly two years (for misdemeanor) to clear the arrest, while the former can do so much sooner.  But the problem still arises that the person needs to take an extra step to protect their privacy.

Texas may want to reexamine their procedures to fall more in line with States that protect their citizen's rights, by waiting for a conviction before reporting and selling criminal history information.  But that approach would obviously lose revenue from the lost sales, so it's doubtful in the near future.

If you have an offense that seems to be rearing it's ugly head on Criminal History Reports, call us for a Free Consultation to see if we can Clear and Destroy your criminal records.

What types of Criminal Cases can I Expunge? When is Expunction Available?

I used to practice in an area where you had the right to have any offense Expunged, even if it resulted in a Conviction.  Obviously it was up to the discretion of the Judge, but a person was afforded the opportunity to clean up their life and move beyond a criminal conviction.  Most common were one-time offenders, who had committed crimes in their youth, typically right around 18-20 years old.  By the time they were 25, they had matured past the typical student/young adult shoplifting offenses, gotten a job, and moved on.  When the Judge saw the person was doing well, with no new offenses, a job, a family, etc..., the record was Expunged.

Texas, however, subscribes to the creed that 'once a criminal, always a criminal.'  Why do I say that?  Because in Texas there is no right to an Expunction on a case that ended in a Conviction.  There are a handful of exceptions or course, such as a person being convicted of underage drinking, which in limited circumstances can be Expunged; but for the most part, once convicted, that offense will remain on your record for your life.

So what can be Expunged? The answer is actually fairly straightforward.  In Texas, a criminal offense can only be Expunged if the case resulted in a Dismissal AND the Dismissal was not the result of a completed Deferred Adjudication probation.  There are a few more questions that need to be asked, such as "did the original arrest result in a final conviction on any reduced or less serious offense?"  If the answer is yes, then you may not be able to Expunge the offense, but more research would be needed.

Expunctions, Motions for Non Disclosure, and Pardons are complex areas of the law, and it's best to talk with a local attorney to find out which options you may have to clear your criminal record.

What is a Texas DPS Departmental Driver's License Suspension? How can I drive legally?

In Texas, there are several ways your Texas Driver's License can be suspended.  Usually your driver's license is suspended from tickets, surcharges, or criminal offenses, but in certain instances, DPS will suspend your license even if you get a warning.

A DPS Departmental License Suspension is an administrative suspension, meaning the suspension is not a criminal punishment.  This "changing of words" is nothing new, and certainly not unique to Texas or DPS; Courts have held throughout the country that it's legal to punish you twice for the same offense, as long as they 'call' one of the punishments "administrative."

For instance, lets assume you are driving on a suspended license.  You get pulled over, given a ticket, and then pay that ticket.  The Judge tells you that your license is now suspended (because of the ticket) for 6 months.  You understand and figure you'll deal with it.

But then, you get a letter in the mail saying DPS, on their own, is ALSO suspending your Texas Driver's License for another year -- ON TOP OF the Court suspension, and based on the same ticket.  You call DPS and say the Judge only suspended your Texas Driver's License for 6 months, but DPS will reply "it's a Departmental Suspension."

DPS will suspend a person's license if they believe they can prove you were driving at a time when your license was suspended.  Since all tickets are routed through DPS, even if you're given a WARNING for your suspended driver's license, and just given a seat belt ticket by the officer during a traffic stop, DPS WILL SUSPEND YOUR LICENSE.

So how do you fight the Departmental Suspension?  You have the right to a hearing, which can be requested WITHIN 10 OR 15 DAYS upon receiving the suspension notice in the mail.  If you miss that date, DPS will say you have waived the hearing and the suspension will stand.  Unfortunately, DPS will not forward mail, so even if you moved and forwarded mail properly through the post office, the suspension letter will not be forwarded.

So if you're having to deal with a Departmental Driver's License suspension in Texas, and have missed the 15 day appeal or ALR hearing, call us right away to talk about other options for your Texas Driver's License.

How a Possession of Marijuana in Austin TX can Suspend your License Forever -- and How to Avoid It.

New laws are being enacted every year, and many are tailored to punishing 'criminals' in creative and illogical ways.  I use 'quotations' over 'criminals' because this article is about Marijuana, and Possession of Marijuana in Texas; and since 10+ states have now either legalized Marijuana, Medical Marijuana, or decriminalized the possession of marijuana.

In Texas, a conviction for Possession of Marijuana (POM) will remain on your criminal record forever, unless the offense is pardoned by the Governor.  There is no right in Texas to Expunge a conviction.  But aside from the potential hardships incurred from a conviction for POM, there is another penalty: a Suspended Driver's License.

Texas DPS will Suspend your Texas Driver's License for SIX MONTHS if you are convicted of POM.  And what's worse, the suspension will last MORE than six months, possibly indefinitely, unless you take the 15 hour Drug Offender Education Program.  once that class is taken, DPS will release the hold on your license, and you will then be eligible for reinstatement (after of course paying close to $135 in DPS reinstatement fees).

While it seems minor (and the country in general seems to agree that Possession of Marijuana for personal use IS minor), a conviction can be costly.  If you have a pending POM, call us for a Free Phone Consultation to discuss how to possibly avoid a conviction on your record, and avoid fees and license suspensions.

Medical Marijuana and Texas: Will your Medical Marijuana Prescription/License be valid in Texas?

Medical Marijuana is now legal in many States, including: Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, DC, Delaware, Hawaii, Maine, Massachusetts, Michigan, Montana, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Washington.

So what happens if you move from one of those states, with a Medical Marijuana License or Card, and move to Austin, Texas?  Is the Medical Marijuana card legal, and can you possession marijuana for medical purposes?  What about cannabis you already had and brought with you?

Unfortunately, the answer to all of the above is a short "no."  In Texas, Cannabis and Marijuana is illegal, regardless of whether another state issued the Cannabis Prescription.  Below, I've listed some frequent questions people ask me:

My Medical Marijuana card is legal and the same as any other medication; Why is it illegal in Texas?  Under the US Constitution, each State may enact their own laws and control their own boundary's, as long as that law does not interfere with or counter a federal law.  Texas does not need to comply with other State laws, unless that law involves a certain right that has been incorporated by the federal government (such as most of the bill of rights).  Currently, Medical Marijuana is not one of those specific incorporated rights, so Texas is free to regulate Marijuana as they wish.

Is it a defense against a POM Arrest if I have the Medical Marijuana card? No, it is NOT a defense. Marijuana is very much illegal in Texas, and if you're unlucky enough to be caught outside of Austin, Travis County, you can end up in jail and/or on probation.  In Travis County, you can usually (with an Attorney) work out a decent plea bargain, but it'll be costly and time consuming.

Can I still grow plants in Texas like I did in California (or any other state)?  No, Cultivation of Cannabis is still illegal in Texas.

What about my Federal Right of Interstate Travel and other rights that allow me to move in the USA? Marijuana Possession is still illegal under Federal Laws, including both interstate travel and intrastate possession.  Because of this, there is no right of interstate travel and other federal rights that you might have with other things, like a Driver's License, etc...